Web Design · Website Redesign

10 Web Design Mistakes That Cost You Enquiries (and How to Fix Them)

By Paul Hendley5 min read

6 August 2024

30 October 2026

Man rubbing his face in frustration while looking at a website on his laptop

The most common web design mistakes aren’t about colours or fonts. They’re the things that stop visitors from finding what they need and getting in touch: a slow site, a confusing menu, a page that’s hard to use on a phone, or no clear next step. Most are easy to spot once you know what to look for, and many can be fixed without starting again.

Below are the ten web design mistakes I see most often when reviewing business websites, along with how to fix each one. If you’re planning a rebuild, they’re also the traps to avoid with your new site.

1. Not making it clear what you do

A homepage headline like “Welcome to our website” or a clever slogan tells visitors nothing. People decide within seconds whether they’re in the right place. Your main heading should say what you do and where, for example “Residential and commercial painter on the Gold Coast”.

The fix: rewrite your homepage headline and first paragraph so a stranger understands your business in one glance.

2. Treating mobile as an afterthought

Many sites are still designed on a big screen and then squeezed onto phones, leaving tiny text, cramped buttons and sideways scrolling. For most local businesses, phones bring in the bulk of visitors, and Google uses the mobile version of your site for ranking.

The fix: test every key page on your own phone, and design for small screens first. My guide to mobile-first design explains the approach.

Web design mistakes cost time: small business owner sitting with parcels and a laptop, looking concerned
Busy business owners don't have time to fight a slow or confusing website, and neither do their customers.

3. A slow website

Huge uncompressed images, auto-playing sliders, too many plugins and cheap hosting all slow a site down, and visitors won’t wait. Google’s Core Web Vitals suggest the main content should load within 2.5 seconds, the page should respond to taps within 200 milliseconds and the layout should stay stable as it loads.

The fix: resize and convert images to WebP, remove plugins and effects you don’t need, and use good hosting with caching. See my article on website speed for a step-by-step approach.

4. Confusing navigation

Menus with too many items, vague labels or important pages hidden three clicks deep make people give up. Visitors expect “Services”, “About” and “Contact” to be where they always are.

The fix: keep the main menu to around five to seven items, use plain labels and put your phone number and main call to action in the header.

5. Weak or missing calls to action

If a visitor is ready to enquire but can’t see how, you’ve lost them. Long forms, a phone number buried in the footer or pages that simply end without a next step are web design mistakes that cost enquiries.

The fix: end every page with one clear action, keep forms short and add a sticky call button on phones.

6. Putting looks ahead of usability

Full-screen videos, animated text and unusual layouts can look impressive in a presentation but frustrate real visitors, especially on mobile data. Light grey text on white, or text over busy photos, is another common problem: the accessibility guidelines recommend a contrast ratio of at least 4.5:1 for body text.

The fix: make every design element earn its place. If it doesn’t help people understand your business or get in touch, simplify it.

7. Ignoring SEO during the design

Design choices affect how well a site ranks. Common web design mistakes here include multiple H1 headings (or none), missing page titles and meta descriptions, text built into images, one page trying to cover every service and no schema markup.

The fix: plan SEO from the start, with one H1 per page, a page for each main service and proper titles and descriptions. I cover this in SEO in web design.

8. Losing rankings in a redesign

Of all the web design mistakes, this is the costliest I see. A business launches a beautiful new site, changes all the page addresses and forgets to set up redirects. Overnight, the pages Google had ranked disappear and enquiries drop.

The fix: before any redesign, list every existing page, keep URLs where you can, and set up 301 redirects from old addresses to the new ones. Check Google Search Console after launch for errors.

Person mapping out a website plan with coloured sticky notes on paper
Mapping every existing page before a redesign makes it easy to plan redirects and protect your rankings.

9. Outdated content and no upkeep

Old prices, staff who left years ago, a blog last updated in 2019 or a copyright date that’s out of date all make visitors wonder whether you’re still trading. Out-of-date WordPress plugins are also a security risk, and a site without a valid SSL certificate triggers browser warnings.

The fix: review your key pages every few months, keep software updated, make sure your SSL certificate is active and keep regular backups.

10. Never testing with real people

Owners know their own site too well to spot its web design mistakes. Watching someone else try to use it is often eye-opening.

The fix: ask a friend or customer to find your phone number, a specific service and your service area on their phone. Note where they hesitate. Google Analytics and Search Console will also show which pages people leave quickly.

How to avoid web design mistakes in a rebuild

If your site has several of these web design mistakes, a fresh start may be better value than patching. When you plan a rebuild, start with your goals and your customers’ questions, keep what’s working (including pages that rank), and test the new site thoroughly on phones before launch. My guide on how to redesign a website walks through the process.

Frequently asked questions

What is the most common web design mistake?

Poor mobile usability is one of the most common web design mistakes. Tiny text, cramped buttons and slow loading on phones cost local businesses a large share of their potential enquiries.

Can web design mistakes affect my Google rankings?

Yes. Slow pages, poor mobile experience, missing titles and headings, and broken redirects after a redesign can all hold your site back in search results.

Should I fix my current website or start again?

If the problems are mostly content, images or calls to action, fixing them is usually enough. If the site is slow, hard to update and not mobile-friendly, a redesign is often better value.

How do I keep my rankings when I redesign my website?

List all existing URLs, keep them where possible, set up 301 redirects for any that change, carry over titles and content that rank, and monitor Google Search Console closely after launch.

Need help fixing these web design mistakes?

If you recognised a few of these web design mistakes on your own site, I can help. I’ll review your website, show you what’s holding it back and, if a rebuild makes sense, handle it properly with redirects and SEO carried over. Learn more about our website redesign services or request a free quote and homepage concept.

Paul Hendley

Written by

Paul Hendley

Paul runs Web Weavers on the Gold Coast and leads a small team of experienced web developers. With more than 20 years in web development, he personally oversees every website and SEO project. More about Paul.

Paul HendleyPaul HendleyWeb Weavers, Gold Coast

Need a website that wins work?

Talk to Paul about a new website, a redesign or SEO. Free quotes, plain answers.

Free homepage concept

See what a modern homepage could look like for your business, before you spend a cent.

Request yours

Work with Web Weavers

Want this done for your business?

Get a website that’s fast, found on Google and built to win enquiries. Our experienced web developers build it, and Paul oversees every detail. No jargon, no hand-offs.